Presidents of the College
| Name | Period |
|---|---|
| Rev. Charles Taylor | 1866–1870 |
| A. G. Murphy (Acting) | 1869–1870 |
| Rev. Benjamin Arbogast | 1870–1873 |
| John Darby | 1873–1875 |
| Rev. Thomas J. Dodd | 1875–1876 |
| Rev. William H. Anderson | 1876–1879 |
| David W. Batson | 1879–1883 |
| Rev. Alexander Redd | 1883–1884 |
| David W. Batson | 1884–1893 |
| Benjamin T. Spencer | 1893–1895 |
| Rev. Eugene H. Pearce | 1895–1900 |
| Rev. John L. Weber | 1901–1906 |
| Henry K. Taylor | 1906–1909 |
| John J. Tigert | 1909–1911 |
| Rev. James L. Clark | 1911–1919 |
| William B. Campbell | 1919–1924 |
| Rev. U. V. W. Darlington | 1924–1925 |
| David C. Hull | 1925–1928 |
| Walter V. Cropper (Acting) | 1928–1929 |
| Dr. Clarence M. Dannelly | 1929–1932 |
| Rev. Reginald V. Bennett | 1932–1937 |
| Rev. Paul S. Powell | 1937–1950 |
| Rev. Dr. John F. Baggett | 1950–1951 |
| Dr. Oscar W. Lever | 1951–1959 |
| Dr. Harold P. Hamilton | 1959–1970 |
| Dr. William E. James | 1971–1979 |
| Dr. Luther W. White | 1979–1988 |
| Dr. Paul W. Hartman | 1988–1993 |
| Dr. Ray C. Purdom (Interim) | 1993–1994 |
| Dr. Wesley H. Poling | 1994–2004 |
| Dr. Anne C. Federlein | 2004–2008 |
| Dr. M. Michael Fagan (Interim) | 2008 |
| Dr. Cheryl D. King | 2008–2011 |
| Dr. Craig Turner | 2011–2014 |
| Barton D. Darrell (President Emeritus) | 2014–2019 |
| Dr. Gene Tice (Interim) | 2019 |
| Dr. Thomas Mitzel | 2020–2024 |
| Dr. James Cousins | 2024–Present |